Monday, February 14, 2011

Comparing Jane Austen and Zora Neal Hurston

Comparing the works, themes, and characteristics of the novels by Jane Austen and Zora Neal Hurston.

Jane Austen (December 16, 1775 – July 18, 1817) was an English novelist. Her work is considered part of the Western canon. Her ability to look deeply into women’s lives and present them in such wonderful balance of form and irony had put her in the ranks of the literary greats of her time. She was considered the most notable and influential novelists of her time although her works then did not receive as warm a reception as in our times. Her literary endeavors did not achieve immense popularity during her lifetime.

Zora Neale Hurston (January 7, 1891-January 28, 1960) was an African-American folklorist. She wrote the critically-acclaimed Harlem Renaissance but was best remembered for her work Their Eyes Were Watching God.

Both authors were better-educated than most girls during their time. Austen entered Reading Ladies boarding school in the Abbey gatehouse in Reading, Berkshire. Hurston took undergraduate studies at Barnard College where she finished a degree B.A. in anthropology in 1928.

Despite a century that gulfed between them, Jane Austen and Zora Neale Hurston are authors that share similar characteristics and themes in their novels.
In consonance with the custom for female authors during her time, Jane Austen was forced to publish her works anonymously. Austen’s works revolved around love stories. During her time the Romantic movement of literature in England was in full bloom. But Austen’s writings were far from being romantic.

Romanticism often borders on passion. Austen, however, extolled love tempered with reason in her novels. She would most likely depict who people practiced moderation in love as having more chances of success than those who went for it at all costs.

In similar grain, we find American author Zora Neale Hurston’s novels reflecting the same values. Moderation is the key she preached. The characters she wrote were not subject to violent or overly emotions. As a matter of fact, anyone could relate to them.

Austen tackled social issues during her time. She delved on issues such as the dilemma of single genteel English women in the early 1800s. During this time, inheritance law and custom favored the male heirs. The bulk of the family’s fortune often went to them, leaving the unmarried women to cope on their own. Austen often depicted socially perceptive comedies on manners in her books. These are particularly true in her work Emma where critics often cited it for perfection of form.

The main plot of both authors’ stories center on the lives of women. Take for instance, Hurston’s book Their Eyes Were Watching God, we find Janie the main protagonist living a sheltered existence. Her grandmother, who was an ex-slave, did not want Janie to experience the harshness in the world. She brought up
Janie in a wealthy environment. As a natural consequence, she revolved around similarly well-to-do black social circle.

Her first husband was Logan who wasn’t able to provide her with financial stability. She was forced to find a job to augment their meager income. As tough times threatened, Janie left him. Her second husband was Jody, a mayor. Jody
brought her to the all black city called Eatonville.

The lifestyles of the people in Eatonville were similar to those of the white people. Her husband, Jody, being the town’s steward, implemented all the rules in the town. As a consequence, the town prospered. Jody, in turn, became financially stable. Somehow, despite her obvious wealth, Janie did not find the happiness she sought. Years rolled by and Jody died. Janie went to the Everglades with Tea Cake and found work in the fields where she was finally able to find true happiness.

Jane Austen’s Sense and Sensibility, which is one of her most popular books, featured two sisters Marianne and Ellinor. Marianne, who, being emotional was acquainted with passionate feelings such as love at first sight. She expressed openly ardent emotions. She admired the grotesque “picturesque”. And she represented Austen’s idea of “sensibility”. Elinor, the sister, was the one blessed with more “sense” as shown by her rational moderation when it came to love. Despite her outlook she still suffered from disappointments brought about by love now and then.

Jane Austen and Zora Neale Hurston provide a strong voice for the issue of feminism in literature. Jane Austen, due to the constraints of her times, was forced to hide her gender and keeping her identity anonymous in order to promote feminist literature. Zora Neale Hurston, on the other hand, continued and promoted the feminist literature movement by her writings. The desired end Zora Neal Hurston had strived though, being a black person herself, was to promote freedom for black people. The issue of Black Liberation Movement, around 1910, was foremost in her times. Their Eyes Were

Watching God, Hurston’s most popular work, carried a themebased on a rural Southern setting. It focused on the relationship between man and nature, the ongoing dynamics of human relationships, and Janie’s thirst for independence.

Authors criticized Zora Neal Hurston because they expected her, being a black author during the black liberation movement in the 1910’s, to write stories depicting black people’s oppression and support the movement by writing about black people struggles for freedom. They wanted Hurston to voice out their experiences on how they are being suppressed by the people around them.
Instead, Zora focused her writings on the issues of the women being suppressed in their rights and not allowed to be free. She seemed largely apolitical. But by tackling this idea, Hurston probably wanted to depict the struggles of black people on their quest for freedom.

In a way, both authors went against popular opinion during their time when they opted not to join the bandwagon. Jane Austen did not pursue romanticism in her novels despite being under the influence of the Romantic Period. Instead, she gave her character like Ellinor a degree of control over her emotions. Zora Neal Hurston, like Austen, did not openly campaign for black independence just like her contemporaries were. She decided to take another route which was to present a more tame view on the movement by tackling women issues and relating them to black people’s struggles.

This is how Hurston deals with pressing issue of racism. Instead of taking sides, she pointed out that black critics during her time were themselves racist against other people. Hurston did not want to limit her view of freedom to a particular group of people alone such as blacks. Freedom for Hurston should be shared by everybody especially freedom from oppression – blacks, Indians, and women.

Austen described in her novels women who were after marriages that would provide them comforts. Readers during our time may find this abhorring but Austen was simply writing the practices during her period. During her time, men and women often married for money. Opportunities for wealth were not widespread. So they turned to marriage as a way to gain financial freedom.

Austen is popular for her ability to intertwine romance with the social situation in her era and produced a believable love story. The conflict in her novels often tackled emotional aspects such as love, friendship and morals being tested by financial concerns.

Just like Austen’s women characters, Hurston’s female lead in Their Eyes Were Watching God particularly Janie also married for money. Her first marriage did not work out because she was used to the life of wealth and abundance. She had not worked a day of her life when she was young being born to a privileged family. Being married to her husband Logan woke her up to the harsh realities that black women her age had to contend. Janie left her first husband in search of a man who could provide for her needs, to find advantageous marriages.

The strength of Austen’s works lies in her ability to give a unique voice on her characters especially women and depicting them in their everyday lives belonging to the middle or upper. It is easy to relate to Jane’s character because they did not out of the ordinary lives. Each woman especially in our generation finds themselves reflected in part by the characters Jane wrote.

Austen’s literary appeal is also due in part in her ability to depict her character vividly and firmly. The characters were always ordinary people who were consistent with their views and principles throughout the story. Austen did not try to embellish them with her own views. But, she managed to preserve the characters’ views all through out.

Just like Austen, Hurston too chose middle and upper class black women in her stories. Their lives just like Austen reflected the lives during their times. Their Eyes Were Watching God by Hurston was able to escape being labeled or attributed to a single movement, whether literary or political. Wright’s criticism about the book which came out in 1937 is, to some degree, true: the book is not a political treatise-it carries no single, overwhelming message or moral. Far from being a weakness, however, this resistance is the secret of the novel’s strength: it is a profoundly rich, multifaceted work that can be read in a number of ways.”


Tuesday, January 11, 2011

William Shakespeare’s Othello, Orson Scott Card’s Ender’s Game, and Speaker For The Dead


In William Shakespeare’s Othello, the protagonist of the same name was a general in Venice. He promoted Florentine Michael Cassio to a higher position of personal lieutenant instead of his friend Iago. This, of course, incurred the ire of Iago. He plotted against Othello and Cassio’s by enlisting the help of Roderigo, the spurned suitor of Desdemona (Othello’s fiancĂ©e).


Iago sowed intrigues between Desdemona and Othello and Othello and Cassio. Iago made Othello jealous by insinuating that Desdemona and Cassio was having an affair. It so inflamed Othello that he decided to kill Desdemona by strangling her, also upon the suggestion of Iago. Cassio got wounded by Roderigo and the death of Desdemona.
Othello later learned belatedly from Emilia, Iago’s wife, that Iago manipulated all the stories. Othello wounded Iago then killed himself. Iago killed Emilia. Iago got imprisoned and Cassio was proclaimed the new governor of Cyrpus.

Orson Scott Card’s Ender`s Game was more gruesome as miscommunication led to the annihilation of an entire race – the alien Formics or better known as the Buggers. Andrew “Ender” Wiggin was a young child-genius who was made to undergo training in preparation for the feared Third Invasion of the alien Buggers. During the first invasion, the alien almost wiped out the entire human population due to lack of technology. The Second Invasion, the human population again almost got eradicated but not as much as the First invasion.

To prevent total eradication of mankind, the International Military Forces enlisted the help of genius children aged five to thirteen to undergo simulated space training that were intended to equip them with skills when the aliens would come.

Ender showed incredible battle skills earning him the Commander post in so short a time. He was then made to undergo a series of simulated battles culminating in the exterminating of the buggers’ planet which in turn killed them. It turned out that the final test was not simulated but the real one. And Ender just committed Xenocide by eliminating the entire Bugger race.

Ender feeling remorseful for his mistake, he together with his sister Valentine, left on a colonization ship bound for the bugger’s destroyed planet where he intended to reside. There, Ender found out that the Buggers’ left him the pupa of the last surviving Queen or the Hive-Queen.

The pupa telepathically talked to Ender and explained to him that the reason why Buggers attacked humans was they believed that humans are not sentient or capable of consciousness. The Buggers realized their error and wanted to make amends by refraining from attacking humans anymore. Therefore, Ender’s Xenocide to defend earth was no longer necessary. Due to lack communication, the bugger could not relay this message to humans which led to the tragic end of the buggers.

Ender related the Queen’s tale by writing a book called “The Hive-Queen” and using the pen name “Speaker for the Dead”. He left the colony and brought the pupa with him to seek a place for the bugger to breed.

Orson Scott Card’s Speaker For The Dead was another tale that delves on miscommunication. But unlike the previous examples, William Shakespeare’s Othello and Ender`s Game, the story did not end tragically. It did not also led to death of humans or the wipe out of an entire alien race. The Speaker For The Dead offers Ender the redemption he so desperately sought after the Xenocide of the Buggers in the preceding book due to miscommunication.

In Speaker for the Dead, Ender was called by his real name Andrew Wiggin. Ender wanted to amend for his previous mistake by working as a speaker for the dead or a person who speaks in behalf of the dead to shed light on their actions or the way they lived their lives.

Another possible miscommunication problem arose in the story when a new specie of intelligent alien called the Pequeninos or popularly known as the “piggies” had been discovered. Conflict arose when the piggies killed two xenologists – Pipo and Libo. The killing started when Novinha discovered the presence of descolada in every life form in Lusitania. The significance of Pipo’s and Libo’s murders was revealed: the piggies do not consider the trees as their gods and do not worship them.

The trees came from dead piggies called the brothertrees. Another tree was the fathertree derived from dissected piggies. These fathertrees are capable of reproduction and are sentient. Descolada aids in the change of piggies to trees. Due to Ender’s efforts, he was able to forge peace between humans and piggies through a signed treaty. In this instance, Ender effectively lessened the harmful effects of miscommunication.

The three tales vividly depict the possible harmful effects of miscommunication among races or peoples. Miscommunication has waged unnecessary wars and took a number of lives. Communication then is a necessary aspect in human relations as shown by the stories.

Iago in Shakespeare’s Othello provided a face to the chilling act on the ease with which communication could be easily twisted in order to create conflicts. Miscommunication could easily be brought upon by people with malicious intentions, people with no conscience and lives for their ulterior selfish motives. People such as Iago are guilty of treachery and falsehood.

Through Iago’s masterful and cunning manipulations, Othello committed the worst act of killing the one he loved most. Then in an act of repentance upon the discovery of truth on how Iago made up stories, he killed himself too. This tragic end goes to show the extent miscommunication could lead to in people’s relationships and lives.

Iago shows a side that is inherent in some people. We can relate to Othello’s plight as we, ourselves, experienced intrigues sown by other people. We hear criticisms, unfair judgment, backbiting and other acts of manipulations. In the process, we feel hurt. We lose friends. We got alienated even to the point of being ostracized. Such is the effect of miscommunication that every person could relate to.

Card’s Ender’s Game provides another facet to the dangers of miscommunication. It is worst than the fate suffered by the characters in Othello as the Buggers met total annihilation due to plain simple miscommunication. The massive xenocide leaves the readers feeling totally deflated. It is simply mind-boggling how a simple lack of communication could lead to such a tragic end. Yet, what makes it so chilling is the fact that that this is realistically possible.

How many times do we see wars explode due to plain miscommunication of motives? Civil wars, wars among countries, genocide were evident in our history. From this nonsense threat of human lives, we see the negative effects lack of communication among leaders, among the government and its peoples and among nations bring. How easily could problems have been avoided if people took the time to sit down and address issues in a more objective way?

Card’s Speaker for the Dead offers us hope in the midst of such grimness. Humans, as we are, miscommunication would be something we need to cope with. With Speaker for the Dead we learned that the hope of eradicating the debilitating effects of miscommunication is found in the act of reaching out to another person or race.

It is indeed ironic that we come to hate what we don’t understand. At the same time, we come to understand only if we stop hating. All three stories depict the kind of hatred that could stem from miscommunication. Hatred could be as total as Iago’s or blinded as Ender’s. But hatred and its dire consequences could be greatly reduced if we all take the time to understand the enemy. At least, if not to understand them, then to stop hating them so we could start the long process of understanding their motives.

People’s motives for doing certain things vary. Some are for their own gain. Others for revenge. Still others, for good intentions. It is a special kind of person who takes the time to stop and listen. There is a thin line between what we perceived reality to be and actual reality. In our haste to view and judge things negatively, we fail to grasps its positive implications. That is why, in the process we end up judging other people’s motives unfavorably.

The problem with miscommunication is it underplays man’s more noble side such as the values of trust and honor. If we hear false accusations about us it is so easy to react negatively. To lose objectivity in the face of unfair accusations. Too often, we fall victim to these unfair lies.

The breakdown of communication such as in the case of Iago would have been greatly reduced if Othello took the time to talk and listen to his beloved Desdemona and his friend, Cassio’s side. The negative consequences of miscommunication would have been avoided if Othello remained objective all along and not let his emotions took over.
Somehow, Othello’s rush judgment offers us a lesson on what to do in the face of intrigues and manipulations.

At some point in our lives, we all come across people who would misunderstand us and our motives. We meet people who have no qualms hurting us and our loved ones by spreading vicious lies. Betrayal is not confined to Iago alone. In our lives, it is almost a certainty that we would stumble across a few Iago’s and fall victim to their wiles. Therefore, it is imperative then that we ready ourselves for such eventuality. We do not want to end up as clueless as Othello.

Basically, to lessen the impact of manipulations I believe it is important to maintain objectivity all throughout. Then weigh options available well before deciding which one to follow. Had Othello took the time to observe with his own eyes and not through someone’s prodding what was actually taking place then he would have avoided the tragic end that he and Desdemona met. He should have get to the heart of the matter first before making rush decisions.

From the stories, we can gather that another good way to prevent miscommunication would be to avoid preconceived notions about the person. For instance, if we look at someone wearing ordinary clothes we naturally assumed that he or she is of average financial status. On the other hand, if we see someone dressed to the nines, we assume that he or she is filthy rich. These misconceptions, of course, could greatly hamper our ability to communicate with the person as we already formed opinions about him or her even before the person speaks.

We could also try to do what Christians normally do in the face of lies and intrigues – we can forgive. By forgiving, we begin to see the person for what he or she truly is. With hatred out of the way, we can be more objective in dealing with the situation and getting to heart of the matter would not be as difficult as when we are under the influence of hatred.

It is sad that during our present times, despite the advances of communication, miscommunication is still a huge problem we faced even on a daily basis. Perhaps if we stop judging and start understanding then we become better communicators and effectively reduce miscommunication in the process.


Monday, November 1, 2010

The Minutemen and Their World by Robert Gross

Book review on award-winning book The Minutemen and Their World by Robert Gross.

Introduction


The Minutemen and Their World by Robert Gross is a winner of the Bancroft Prize. The book first came out in 1976. Recently, it has been reissued in celebration of its twenty-fifth anniversary edition with a new Afterward by the author.

In The Minutemen and Their World, Robert Gross wrote a subtle and in-depth depiction of the people and community of this special place. It is a convincing explanation of the American Revolution, depicting it as a social movement.

 

Summary of Book


The Minutemen and Their World offers a glimpse of the lives of the people living in the colonial period in Concord Massachusetts; this is where the Revolutionary War in Robert Gross’s book starts. Gross, “sets the Concord Fight, as it used to be known, in the context of the townspeople’s ordinary lives, before and after April 19, 1775. It examines how the citizens farmed the land, raised their families, and carried on their politics at the end of the colonial period.”

On April 19, 1775, the American Revolution took place at the Old North Bridge in Concord, Massachusetts. The “shot heard round the world” became the wake up call that put the peaceful New England town at the center revolution. Concord’s image took a major shift and its growing popularity hinged on its being the intellectual capital of the new republic. The town where Emerson, Thoreau, and Hawthorne came from symbolized commitment to liberty, intellectual independence, and the firm integrity of the rural life.

 

Author’s Main Theme


The major themes revolved on how people viewed the British invasion, their thoughts on imposed taxes and tariffs, and an overview of life in general during the period. The book depicts the life of people in Concord, Massachusetts to serve as an example for the bigger picture or the overall story on the American Revolution.

Gross points out that the struggle for independence from Britain is not to be considered as a revolution but a cautious social struggle against the pressing issues of the day – patriarchal governance, religious fanaticism, individualism, and restricted government control.

 

Author’s Message


Gross’ message contained in the book is that the Revolution is a means for people of Concord to have a clear grasp on the situation and be able to direct its own course. In 1775-1776, great changes occurred in the colonies, particularly Concord. The urgent concerns include decreasing supplies of land, desire of its residents to hire their own minister.

With all these problems, participation in the Revolution gave Concord an opportunity to exercise initiative and regain rule on its political and communal life, bring back independence. Gross says, “The men of 1775 had not gone to war to promote change but to stop it.”

 

Writer’s Style


In the book, Gross augmented the book’s information by using historical public records to relate a story, associating emotion and motivation with the statistical trends. Quantitative data was presented subjectively and to avoid biases Gross allows the reader to draw his own conclusions.

 

Strengths and Weaknesses


In the book, the most persuasive argument Gross points out is the loss of patriarchal control in Concord, and even across the colonies. His vivid description how sons rely on fathers for land, and daughters rely on fathers for dowries sets the tone of the story.

When drastic changes occurred economically, dowries are affected, local fertile land becomes scant and grown children leave the family to pursue the frontier. In turn, the father loses source of labor (slavery was not popular in Massachusetts) and the children lose inheritance and stability. Gross approaches each argument in a similar manner – he tells a personal story backed by quantitative research. This makes the story more effective because it presents facts in a very interesting manner, something which anyone can relate to emotionally.

 

Conclusion

The Minutemen and Their World was revolutionary in the sense that it personalizes a Revolution. The author added to the understanding of the Revolution by presenting historical records and statistics and intertwine it with the lives and motivations to all of Concord’s citizens – great men, but also average people: poor men, widows, spinsters, ministers, blacks, farmers, blacksmiths, intellectuals, substitutes, and dissenters.

The arguments are based solidly on facts because of the great quantitative research, but the author sometimes wonders “if the Minutemen would recognize themselves in my mirror”. Academics sometimes use Gross’s work to compare Vietnam to the American Revolution but Gross does not include it in the main text. This is a must read for students who wants to know about the Revolution in great detail.

Sunday, October 10, 2010

"Ordinary Men" By Christopher R. Browning

The Holocaust presented not only the atrocities committed against the Jews in particular; it was more so a testament of atrocities committed against humanity in general. Browning uses as a basis for his story a compilation of documentation gathered on postwar German interrogations of men of comprising this unit who carried out the wartime atrocities. He takes a deeper look at the Reserve Police Battalion 101 from Hamburg composed mostly middle-aged men from artisans and working class non-career police reservists. These men were either too old for normal front-line service or those who had no desire to practice a career in the police outside their role in this reserve unit.

In the book, Browning describes the dangerous use of even these units as first guards on trains that used to bring Jews to extermination camps. These units also participated in the in the rounding up Jews in the Polish Ghettos. Later, they exterminate entire villages.

This unit made up of 500 men broke down further into police reservists that did not have combat skills and were not central to the holocaust activity turned out to be the ones directly responsible for the killing of 38,000 people by shooting them to death. Also, they were directly responsible in transporting 100,000 thousand others to their deaths.

Browning turned back the hands of time by showing us what kind of men made up this unit. They were a diverse class of Party members, members of the SS, working or privileged upper higher classes and others. Their first act of killing was looked into in detail. All members of the Police Battalion 101 unit were not aware that they were to shoot unarmed and utterly helpless Jews.

What could possibly draw supposedly decent people comprising Police Battalion 101 to do such ghastly acts? Some cite the need to do so since they were in battlefield. But many believed this assumption is wrong. Those in the Battalion as a matter of fact were not skilled in combat training since most were older men.

Browning could be creating controversy when he called the book "ordinary men" to refer to the members of the Police Battalion 101. Their extraordinary callous acts could be attributed to the decaying effect of the racialist Nazi that was considered as the accepted truth in German society that brought the war. Browning does not give specific answer to the question as to why the atrocities occurred and why they were committed by seemingly good people. Those interviewed members of the unit did not bother to answer the question themselves. It is however the subject of confusion and the focus of the story as to how an ordinary person could kill children, women and old men with little or no remorse. It causes us to look closely and ask ourselves: how can racialist ideologies turned ordinary men into extraordinary monsters? That is the one question posed by the book which it did not address.

Monday, June 7, 2010

The Metamorphosis” by Franz Kafka

A book review on the classic “The Metamorphosis” by Franz Kafka.

“The Metamorphosis” by Franz Kafka is a heart-wrenching tale of a young man named Gregor who worked so hard for the welfare of his family. One morning he woke up and saw that he was no longer a man but metamorphosed into a vermin probably a roach. He wanted so much to continue working to help his family but his present state prevented him to do so. His metamorphosis proved to be a huge adjustment for him and his family. Later, he experienced alienation from them. Until, he lost his desire to live and perished.

Metamorphosis is an allegory to Gregor's struggle. Gregor's uncommon sacrifices to provide for his family's needs forced him to lead a life similar to that of a bug long before the transformation actually occurred. Gregor's transformation first occurred within and it manifested physically when he metamorphosed into a vermin.

We could see Gregor complaining at the start of the story. He thought that his transformation into a giant insect was a nightmare that he could simply wish away. So he shifted his thoughts to things that matter to him. We could see here that despite his present condition, Gregor's thoughts still centered on his work so he could support his family.

Gregor willingly sacrificed his welfare for his family but when he transformed into a giant insect he became a burden to them. Gregor therefore no longer serves any purpose for his parents. He was treated as a commodity. He was exploited to be able to support their expensive lifestyle. Yet, in the end, Gregor did not even get the respect and care he so richly deserved.

Equally disturbing is the last paragraph of the story. After Gregor died and the family was finally able to resume normal life, they turned their attention to Grete whom they have overlooked during their struggles. Since the parents had no use for Gregor anymore, they now focus their attention on his younger sister. Despite Gregor's terrible fate, the parents still find it in them to prioritize their whims by exploiting their daughter.

The Metamorphosis could be intended by the author to be satirical indictment of the bourgeois society and its demands. Or it could be Gregor's feelings of alienation and unspoken needs. These unspoken desires were probably crushed by authority and the boredom of the daily grind as attested by Gregor's sad fate. Whatever reasons are behind Gregor's metamorphosis, it all boils down to the fact that it occurred because he allowed himself to deteriorate. This in turn reduced him to a state at par with the insects robbing him of his unique traits and identity as a human being.